Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Magazine
  • April 1, 1875
  • Page 17
Current:

The Masonic Magazine, April 1, 1875: Page 17

  • Back to The Masonic Magazine, April 1, 1875
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article EARLY HISTORY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY, ONCE MORE. ← Page 2 of 4 →
Page 17

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Early History Of American Freemasonry, Once More.

this belief , that I even Avrote to the Freemason earl y in 1873 about it ; but am sorry to say , the communication Avas not printed . In that article I took occasion to confess an error I made in my review of the Price address , August 17 th ,

1872 . I suppose that the date of the Byelaws , October 24 th , 1733 , did not correspond with the regular lodge night of the lodge , while October 24 th , 1753 , does correspond with its regular night , and advanced this as a point in argument to SIIOAV that the date was altered . This , however , was only one of my reasons on that subject . Bro . Shurtleff ' s almanack shoAved that

both in 1733 and 1753 , October 26 th fell on Wednesday ; After the demise of the late Bro . C . W . Moore , the records of the first lodge of the Master Masons' Lodge , and of the second lodge Avere found in his safe . I Avas

right , then , that the record was not burnt . On the title page of the first lodge record is written , presented by "Thomas Walker , S . W ., 1738 . " Price ' s Deputation , including April thirtieth , is first on the record . Next are the Bye-Lawsdated as Bro . Moore said

, , 1733 . Here I Avas Avrong , and Bro . Moore was ri ght . In Avhose handwriting these entries were made 1 know not . The first recorded minutes of a lodge meeting , is not Jul y 30 th , 1733-5733 , but December 27 th , 1738 . Here Bro . Moore

and I Avere both Avrong . He for asserting that it began July 30 th , etc ., and I for believing him . The date July 30 th cannot even be found in the record . During the first year Eben Swan acted as secretary . The minutes are meagre . On the 26 th

December , 1733 , the name of P . or Peter Pelham appears as secretary . I folloAved up the record until September 12 th , IV 44 , P . Pelham still secretary . On that night , Charles Pelham , the writer of the G . L . record from 1733 was

, initiated ; corresponding with the date on the first lod ge list Avhich was also Avritten hy him . On the folloAving page , September -6 th , 17-14 , C . Pelham is already secretary , and so he continued till the close of the hook in 1754 .

I confess it puzzled me . It was not exactl y as I expected , but yet I was in the main a p right . Though Peter ' s name appears on the record as secretary , yet it is an undeniable fact , that from December 26 th , 1739 , to the close of the book , it is

all in Charles Pelham s handAvriting . The conclusion I therefore came to Avas this : Thomas Walker , AVIIO was S . W . in 1738 , presented the book to the lodge , not in 1738 , but about the year 1753 . He never held a hig her office in the lodge than S . W .

hence that title and the date he held that office is mentioned , ancl the list of tho members of that lodge Avas no doubt designed to be Avorked into the record . There is this difference between the G . L . and lodge record ; for the latter , Pelham

no doubt possessed some materials , such as money accounts and documents Avhich he found among his father's papers . But for the G . L . record , he possessed only the deputations of Price , Tomlinson , and Oxnardand also the petition for

con-, stituting the undersigned into a lodge . The rest he gave merely from hearsay . Tho G . L . record is nothing but a tissue of errors , anachronisms , and utterly untrustworthy as evidence . Of the four documents recorded in itthe only original copy

remain-, ing is the petition . But on comparing the orig inal MS . with the one recorded , it Avill be seen , that Pelham Avas unreliable even as a copyist . I send Avith this , the

two copies , p laced side by side , Avhich will SIIOAV at a glance , that the recorded one is altered ancl garbled . The G . L . record is so artlessly done , that in less than a quarter of an hour ' s examination I concluded that it Avas not authentic , and that it Avas not

Avritten before 1750-1 or 2 . But the lodge record Avas more carefully done . Pelham got the secretary of 1738 to write up his ' part . Had Peter Pelham been living , Peter would probably have written for those years that he served as secretary ;

but Peter Pelham died in December , 1751 , ancl the record Avas not Avritten before 1754 . And it may seem strange that from 1754 to 1784 , the same lodge Avas again Avithout a record , that is , there is no evidence nor tradition that it kept a record during those

thirty years . I suppose that there Avas no other P . S . W . to present the lodge Avith a book as Bro . Walker did . The Master Masons' record begins in 1738 . I did not notice the name of the secretary ; then several pages are left blank .

But in 1743 the record begins again , and from that date , until 1754 , Avith the exception of a very feAV pages , Avas all clone by the hand of Charles Pelham . The blank pages were probabl y designed for the V

“The Masonic Magazine: 1875-04-01, Page 17” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 14 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmg/issues/mmg_01041875/page/17/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Monthly Masonic Summary. Article 1
THE MASONIC MEASURE OF LIFE. Article 1
THE PUBLIC MASONIC CHARITIES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Article 2
VERSES WRITTEN ON BOARD A LOUGH ERNE STEAMER , Article 6
WAITING FOR HER—A MESMERIST'S STORY. Article 7
FREEMASONRY CONSIDERED IN ITS RELATION TO SOCIETY. Article 10
A SERIOUS TALK. Article 13
RECOLLECTION. Article 15
EARLY HISTORY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY, ONCE MORE. Article 16
THE ADVENTURES AND TRAVELS OF A BOX OF BONBONS. Article 19
EHEU FUGACES ANNI, O POSTUME! Article 22
Reviews. Article 23
FAITH, HOPE, AND CHARITY. Article 27
OLD LONDON TAVERNS IDENTIFIED WITH MASONRY. Article 28
TIME AND ETERNITY. Article 30
HOW TO CONDUCT A COURTSHIP. Article 31
A TRUE MASON. Article 31
I MUSED LAST NIGHT IN PENSIVE MOOD. Article 32
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

2 Articles
Page 23

Page 23

2 Articles
Page 24

Page 24

1 Article
Page 25

Page 25

1 Article
Page 26

Page 26

1 Article
Page 27

Page 27

2 Articles
Page 28

Page 28

1 Article
Page 29

Page 29

1 Article
Page 30

Page 30

3 Articles
Page 31

Page 31

3 Articles
Page 32

Page 32

3 Articles
Page 17

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Early History Of American Freemasonry, Once More.

this belief , that I even Avrote to the Freemason earl y in 1873 about it ; but am sorry to say , the communication Avas not printed . In that article I took occasion to confess an error I made in my review of the Price address , August 17 th ,

1872 . I suppose that the date of the Byelaws , October 24 th , 1733 , did not correspond with the regular lodge night of the lodge , while October 24 th , 1753 , does correspond with its regular night , and advanced this as a point in argument to SIIOAV that the date was altered . This , however , was only one of my reasons on that subject . Bro . Shurtleff ' s almanack shoAved that

both in 1733 and 1753 , October 26 th fell on Wednesday ; After the demise of the late Bro . C . W . Moore , the records of the first lodge of the Master Masons' Lodge , and of the second lodge Avere found in his safe . I Avas

right , then , that the record was not burnt . On the title page of the first lodge record is written , presented by "Thomas Walker , S . W ., 1738 . " Price ' s Deputation , including April thirtieth , is first on the record . Next are the Bye-Lawsdated as Bro . Moore said

, , 1733 . Here I Avas Avrong , and Bro . Moore was ri ght . In Avhose handwriting these entries were made 1 know not . The first recorded minutes of a lodge meeting , is not Jul y 30 th , 1733-5733 , but December 27 th , 1738 . Here Bro . Moore

and I Avere both Avrong . He for asserting that it began July 30 th , etc ., and I for believing him . The date July 30 th cannot even be found in the record . During the first year Eben Swan acted as secretary . The minutes are meagre . On the 26 th

December , 1733 , the name of P . or Peter Pelham appears as secretary . I folloAved up the record until September 12 th , IV 44 , P . Pelham still secretary . On that night , Charles Pelham , the writer of the G . L . record from 1733 was

, initiated ; corresponding with the date on the first lod ge list Avhich was also Avritten hy him . On the folloAving page , September -6 th , 17-14 , C . Pelham is already secretary , and so he continued till the close of the hook in 1754 .

I confess it puzzled me . It was not exactl y as I expected , but yet I was in the main a p right . Though Peter ' s name appears on the record as secretary , yet it is an undeniable fact , that from December 26 th , 1739 , to the close of the book , it is

all in Charles Pelham s handAvriting . The conclusion I therefore came to Avas this : Thomas Walker , AVIIO was S . W . in 1738 , presented the book to the lodge , not in 1738 , but about the year 1753 . He never held a hig her office in the lodge than S . W .

hence that title and the date he held that office is mentioned , ancl the list of tho members of that lodge Avas no doubt designed to be Avorked into the record . There is this difference between the G . L . and lodge record ; for the latter , Pelham

no doubt possessed some materials , such as money accounts and documents Avhich he found among his father's papers . But for the G . L . record , he possessed only the deputations of Price , Tomlinson , and Oxnardand also the petition for

con-, stituting the undersigned into a lodge . The rest he gave merely from hearsay . Tho G . L . record is nothing but a tissue of errors , anachronisms , and utterly untrustworthy as evidence . Of the four documents recorded in itthe only original copy

remain-, ing is the petition . But on comparing the orig inal MS . with the one recorded , it Avill be seen , that Pelham Avas unreliable even as a copyist . I send Avith this , the

two copies , p laced side by side , Avhich will SIIOAV at a glance , that the recorded one is altered ancl garbled . The G . L . record is so artlessly done , that in less than a quarter of an hour ' s examination I concluded that it Avas not authentic , and that it Avas not

Avritten before 1750-1 or 2 . But the lodge record Avas more carefully done . Pelham got the secretary of 1738 to write up his ' part . Had Peter Pelham been living , Peter would probably have written for those years that he served as secretary ;

but Peter Pelham died in December , 1751 , ancl the record Avas not Avritten before 1754 . And it may seem strange that from 1754 to 1784 , the same lodge Avas again Avithout a record , that is , there is no evidence nor tradition that it kept a record during those

thirty years . I suppose that there Avas no other P . S . W . to present the lodge Avith a book as Bro . Walker did . The Master Masons' record begins in 1738 . I did not notice the name of the secretary ; then several pages are left blank .

But in 1743 the record begins again , and from that date , until 1754 , Avith the exception of a very feAV pages , Avas all clone by the hand of Charles Pelham . The blank pages were probabl y designed for the V

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 16
  • You're on page17
  • 18
  • 32
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy