Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • March 1, 1857
  • Page 5
Current:

The Masonic Observer, March 1, 1857: Page 5

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, March 1, 1857
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article GRAND LODGE OF EMERGENCY. ← Page 2 of 4 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Emergency.

W . Bro . the Rev . G . PORTAL said he was quite ready to agree to the motion being amended , so that the return should be ordered by 0 L . through the G . Secretary . The motion was then agreed to .

INTOLERANCE OF THE WOMAN CATHOLIC PKIESTHOOD . Bro . the EA RL of CA RNA RVON then moved , that" the Grand Lodge having seen with regret the antagonistic position assumed by the Roman Catholic Church towards Masonry , desires the Board of General Purposes to draw up a statement of the principles of the Order , that the same may be sent to the masters of all Lodges under the Grand Lodge of England , in Roman Catholic Countries , to be used by them as they shall think fit . " He very much regretted that this motion should have fallen to his share ; the subject was so

important , was of such deep interest to so many parties , not being confined to tliis or any other Country , but extending over the whole world , that he should have rejoiced to have seen it brought forward by some worshipful Brother , of higher standing and experience , whose words would fall with greater weight , and have more effect , than he could possibly expect in his own case . But in the absence of such an influential worshipful Brother he cheerfully accepted the duty of coming forward with the motion on the paper . It was painful to dwell on the subject of the motion ; on the persecution which so

many of their brethren abroad suffered , on account of their adherence to Freemasonry . It was the more painful to feel that there existed at this day a Hierarchy , which believed that its pretensions were upheld , and " the cause of Religion advanced , by placing under the ban of excommunication , and by inflicting acts of oppression on Freemasons—on individuals who were members of their church , who refused to comply with no ceremony , who did not refuse their assent to a single dogma , and who only claimed the right of entering

into membership with the society of Freemasons . Unfortunately however , the case was as he had stated it ; the Roman Catholic Hierarchy now as in former times did not hesitate to denounce any study or pursuit , which she did not either control or sanction . j Unfortunately they were not to be taught by the experience of the past that such a strife must be unsuccessful , and that no pretensions could abide on such a frail and slender foundation . In other ages and countries , and even to this day , wherever the Roman Catholic Church had sway , the name of Freemason was synonymous with atheist . The pure doctrines of Freemasonry , in those countries , continued to be regarded with suspicion—he had himself heard Freemasonry calumniated , traduced , and loaded with

the most monstrous calumnies . And thus it was in former timessocieties which reflected similar organization , and principles , were persecuted , and suffered in the same way . Their Great Order , Freemasonry , was so oppressed , but their predecessors never swerved , or doubted ; they steadily adhered to the principles of the Order—they fought a gallant fight , and they ultimately achieved victory . ( Cheers . ) And he felt persuaded if the successors of those gallant Masons in foreign countries were again assailed , they would struggle in defence of their princilesand those struggles would

p , ultimately meet a like reward . He would not go into details of oppression at present . In many parts of the world , Roman Catholic Freemasons were at that moment undergoing severe personal inconvenience , and were even interdicted from participating in their civil and religious privileges . ( No . ) A worshipful Brother said "no , " but he would tell hiin that Roman Catholics , because Freemasons , had been refused by their priests the rites of marriage and burial ( hear ); and if that was not interfering with their civil and religious privileges

he did not know what such interference meant . He understood that a communication had been received from a country with which we had hitherto greatly sympathized , that the Grand Master of France had addressed the Grand Master of England , entreating his advice and co-operation in the present crisis of affairs , and that that communication had been left for months without a reply . ( Hear . ) He had beard something on that head , but he would give credence to no report until it was confirmed officially . He would only say he hoped it would be contradicted . No one would more sincerely

rejoice than he would to hear a denial of this publicly made . The remedy he proposed for the lamentable condition of things ho had indicated was simply this—that those Masons well versed in the principles and history of the order be requested , with the greatest dispatch and care , to frame a statement of the principles which governed the Society of Freemasons in every age . If Freemasonry had one great principle , one main-spring of its existence , it was religion . If there was another principle equally well established , it was that Freemasons rigidly declined to interfere in political matters . The great Society of Freemasons had seen the rise and fall of potent nations in the past ages of the world—of Carthage , of Greece , of Rome—it had seen ancient and modern institutions fade , and it had

survived and flourished over all , because the end and object it had in view were of a universal and an enduring character . He trusted the statement which his motion contemplated would be framed in a conciliatory and a temperate manner , for he felt assured , if his plan was carried out with judgment and prudence , it would do much to sooth existing prejudice , and to allay unworthy douljt and distrust . XV . BRO . AIUA yielded to no member of that Lodge , however distinguished , in those feelings which , on such an occasion , he conceived ought to animate every brother Mason and every man . In

rising thus early to second the motion , he did so in the hope of inducing the Noble Brother to introduce other words into the motion , so as to make it more universal in its application . It was known that lately the King of Hanover had consented to become Grand Master of a Freemasons' Lodge , in which Jews were not admitted . Now , by this , the King appeared to wish to promulgate to the world that Freemasonry was a Christian Order , and that only those who professed Christianity were to be admitted into the Order . This was a matter for the Grand Lodge to take into consideration

quite as much as the matter comprised in the wish of his Noble brother . Nothing more subversive of the true principles of Freemasonry could be introduced than such an exclusion . Let the principles that actuated them as men , Masons , and gentlemen be known , and let it also be known that the widest toleration of all creeds was the foundation stone of Masonry . He hoped his Noble brother would alter his motion , which , if necessary to the Roman Catholic Church , was necessary to the Protestant Church likewise . If carried in its present formhe feared the motion would attract

, little notice and carry less weight . Bro . the EARL of CARSAHVON had , individually , no objection to alter the motion so as to make it more general . He thought , however , the making of it particular , made it more consistent with its importance . R . W . Bro . HAVERS confessed that he never addressed the Grand Lodge with greater emotion than on the present occasion . Giving the greatest credit to the feelings which a and enthusiastic

young Mason might well be supposed to possess on such a question , he could have wished that no Mason had ever given expression to sentiments which that noble Brother had uttered . Agreeing with all he had said in reprobation of oppression—agreeing with all he had uttered in the way of sympathy towards our foreign brethren , still

he could not help deploring that the question of religion had been raised , or that any Mason had uttered a word of reproach against any religion . If any brother , whatever his position or object—if any brother could bo permitted to stand up and rate in set terms the professors of other religions , that principle of permission must apply to one and all . If necessary to rate the Roman Catholic , why not rate the Jew ? Such a course was contrary to the spirit of the Craft . He said it in the earnest spirit of a true Mason , that he hoped the words of the noble Brother would be confined to the walls

of the Grand Lodge , and remain with those who heard them . If spread throughout the world , they might assist to cut away one of the main foundations of the Craft—its tolerant and unsectarian spirit . He was satisfied that nothing would be taken by the motion , for it was the principle of Freemasonry to interfere with no man ' s religion . But this motion could not be carried ; the means were inadequate to effect ifs avowed objects . Certain individuals complained of persecution—were they going to send the statement of principles to

the persecutors ? No—they were going to send it to the members of the Lodges were persecution took place , who were already well enough instr uctcd in their own principles . Perhaps they proposed to send the statement to somebody else—to the Roman Catholic priests ; but it was not the priests who were persecutors ; they were onl y carrying out instructions , which they were bound to obey . He had been in Paris lately , and had there heard Roman Catholic priests approve of the principles of Masonry , and at the same time avow they had the

no discretionary power on subject of giving freemasons marriage and burial rites . Well then , if it was no use applying to the priests , he supposed they would have to send a remonstrance to the pope , to entreat him not to persecute Freemasons . But the pope might say , that it would be first as well to do what they could to prevent one set of brothers from excluding Jews . Then it was said , that this statement was to be sent to the different Lodges in Roman Catholic countries ; but he askedwhere were those Lod ?

, ges he knew of none except in South America . Ho protested against interference in matters of religion . Look at the Mauritius , they sent a petition to France , and because the French Lodges could not deal with it , they sent it to the Grand Lodge here to be dealt with . Last December twelvemonth , a petition was sent here on which the present motion was founded ; that petition was suffered to drop without remark , vote , or sympathy . ( No . ) He must remind the Grand Lodge , that the selection of the Freemasons' Society was a

“The Masonic Observer: 1857-03-01, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_01031857/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 4
GRAND LODGE OF EMERGENCY. Article 4
"ADDRESS TO THE CRAFT, BY A PAST MASTER." Article 8
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Article 10
MEMORIAL FROM THE PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF CANADA WEST. Article 10
BRO. THE EARL OF CARNARVON AT BATH. Article 12
A VALENTINE SOMEWHAT OVERDUE. Article 13
"THE MASONIC OBSERVER" TO HIS SHAMELESS LITTLE MUSE. Article 13
Untitled Article 14
Correspondence. Article 14
Untitled Article 15
From the " Canadian Masonic Pioneer." Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
"THE EARLY WITHDRAWAL OF THE BENEVOLENT—A LESSON TO SURVIVORS." Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

7 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Emergency.

W . Bro . the Rev . G . PORTAL said he was quite ready to agree to the motion being amended , so that the return should be ordered by 0 L . through the G . Secretary . The motion was then agreed to .

INTOLERANCE OF THE WOMAN CATHOLIC PKIESTHOOD . Bro . the EA RL of CA RNA RVON then moved , that" the Grand Lodge having seen with regret the antagonistic position assumed by the Roman Catholic Church towards Masonry , desires the Board of General Purposes to draw up a statement of the principles of the Order , that the same may be sent to the masters of all Lodges under the Grand Lodge of England , in Roman Catholic Countries , to be used by them as they shall think fit . " He very much regretted that this motion should have fallen to his share ; the subject was so

important , was of such deep interest to so many parties , not being confined to tliis or any other Country , but extending over the whole world , that he should have rejoiced to have seen it brought forward by some worshipful Brother , of higher standing and experience , whose words would fall with greater weight , and have more effect , than he could possibly expect in his own case . But in the absence of such an influential worshipful Brother he cheerfully accepted the duty of coming forward with the motion on the paper . It was painful to dwell on the subject of the motion ; on the persecution which so

many of their brethren abroad suffered , on account of their adherence to Freemasonry . It was the more painful to feel that there existed at this day a Hierarchy , which believed that its pretensions were upheld , and " the cause of Religion advanced , by placing under the ban of excommunication , and by inflicting acts of oppression on Freemasons—on individuals who were members of their church , who refused to comply with no ceremony , who did not refuse their assent to a single dogma , and who only claimed the right of entering

into membership with the society of Freemasons . Unfortunately however , the case was as he had stated it ; the Roman Catholic Hierarchy now as in former times did not hesitate to denounce any study or pursuit , which she did not either control or sanction . j Unfortunately they were not to be taught by the experience of the past that such a strife must be unsuccessful , and that no pretensions could abide on such a frail and slender foundation . In other ages and countries , and even to this day , wherever the Roman Catholic Church had sway , the name of Freemason was synonymous with atheist . The pure doctrines of Freemasonry , in those countries , continued to be regarded with suspicion—he had himself heard Freemasonry calumniated , traduced , and loaded with

the most monstrous calumnies . And thus it was in former timessocieties which reflected similar organization , and principles , were persecuted , and suffered in the same way . Their Great Order , Freemasonry , was so oppressed , but their predecessors never swerved , or doubted ; they steadily adhered to the principles of the Order—they fought a gallant fight , and they ultimately achieved victory . ( Cheers . ) And he felt persuaded if the successors of those gallant Masons in foreign countries were again assailed , they would struggle in defence of their princilesand those struggles would

p , ultimately meet a like reward . He would not go into details of oppression at present . In many parts of the world , Roman Catholic Freemasons were at that moment undergoing severe personal inconvenience , and were even interdicted from participating in their civil and religious privileges . ( No . ) A worshipful Brother said "no , " but he would tell hiin that Roman Catholics , because Freemasons , had been refused by their priests the rites of marriage and burial ( hear ); and if that was not interfering with their civil and religious privileges

he did not know what such interference meant . He understood that a communication had been received from a country with which we had hitherto greatly sympathized , that the Grand Master of France had addressed the Grand Master of England , entreating his advice and co-operation in the present crisis of affairs , and that that communication had been left for months without a reply . ( Hear . ) He had beard something on that head , but he would give credence to no report until it was confirmed officially . He would only say he hoped it would be contradicted . No one would more sincerely

rejoice than he would to hear a denial of this publicly made . The remedy he proposed for the lamentable condition of things ho had indicated was simply this—that those Masons well versed in the principles and history of the order be requested , with the greatest dispatch and care , to frame a statement of the principles which governed the Society of Freemasons in every age . If Freemasonry had one great principle , one main-spring of its existence , it was religion . If there was another principle equally well established , it was that Freemasons rigidly declined to interfere in political matters . The great Society of Freemasons had seen the rise and fall of potent nations in the past ages of the world—of Carthage , of Greece , of Rome—it had seen ancient and modern institutions fade , and it had

survived and flourished over all , because the end and object it had in view were of a universal and an enduring character . He trusted the statement which his motion contemplated would be framed in a conciliatory and a temperate manner , for he felt assured , if his plan was carried out with judgment and prudence , it would do much to sooth existing prejudice , and to allay unworthy douljt and distrust . XV . BRO . AIUA yielded to no member of that Lodge , however distinguished , in those feelings which , on such an occasion , he conceived ought to animate every brother Mason and every man . In

rising thus early to second the motion , he did so in the hope of inducing the Noble Brother to introduce other words into the motion , so as to make it more universal in its application . It was known that lately the King of Hanover had consented to become Grand Master of a Freemasons' Lodge , in which Jews were not admitted . Now , by this , the King appeared to wish to promulgate to the world that Freemasonry was a Christian Order , and that only those who professed Christianity were to be admitted into the Order . This was a matter for the Grand Lodge to take into consideration

quite as much as the matter comprised in the wish of his Noble brother . Nothing more subversive of the true principles of Freemasonry could be introduced than such an exclusion . Let the principles that actuated them as men , Masons , and gentlemen be known , and let it also be known that the widest toleration of all creeds was the foundation stone of Masonry . He hoped his Noble brother would alter his motion , which , if necessary to the Roman Catholic Church , was necessary to the Protestant Church likewise . If carried in its present formhe feared the motion would attract

, little notice and carry less weight . Bro . the EARL of CARSAHVON had , individually , no objection to alter the motion so as to make it more general . He thought , however , the making of it particular , made it more consistent with its importance . R . W . Bro . HAVERS confessed that he never addressed the Grand Lodge with greater emotion than on the present occasion . Giving the greatest credit to the feelings which a and enthusiastic

young Mason might well be supposed to possess on such a question , he could have wished that no Mason had ever given expression to sentiments which that noble Brother had uttered . Agreeing with all he had said in reprobation of oppression—agreeing with all he had uttered in the way of sympathy towards our foreign brethren , still

he could not help deploring that the question of religion had been raised , or that any Mason had uttered a word of reproach against any religion . If any brother , whatever his position or object—if any brother could bo permitted to stand up and rate in set terms the professors of other religions , that principle of permission must apply to one and all . If necessary to rate the Roman Catholic , why not rate the Jew ? Such a course was contrary to the spirit of the Craft . He said it in the earnest spirit of a true Mason , that he hoped the words of the noble Brother would be confined to the walls

of the Grand Lodge , and remain with those who heard them . If spread throughout the world , they might assist to cut away one of the main foundations of the Craft—its tolerant and unsectarian spirit . He was satisfied that nothing would be taken by the motion , for it was the principle of Freemasonry to interfere with no man ' s religion . But this motion could not be carried ; the means were inadequate to effect ifs avowed objects . Certain individuals complained of persecution—were they going to send the statement of principles to

the persecutors ? No—they were going to send it to the members of the Lodges were persecution took place , who were already well enough instr uctcd in their own principles . Perhaps they proposed to send the statement to somebody else—to the Roman Catholic priests ; but it was not the priests who were persecutors ; they were onl y carrying out instructions , which they were bound to obey . He had been in Paris lately , and had there heard Roman Catholic priests approve of the principles of Masonry , and at the same time avow they had the

no discretionary power on subject of giving freemasons marriage and burial rites . Well then , if it was no use applying to the priests , he supposed they would have to send a remonstrance to the pope , to entreat him not to persecute Freemasons . But the pope might say , that it would be first as well to do what they could to prevent one set of brothers from excluding Jews . Then it was said , that this statement was to be sent to the different Lodges in Roman Catholic countries ; but he askedwhere were those Lod ?

, ges he knew of none except in South America . Ho protested against interference in matters of religion . Look at the Mauritius , they sent a petition to France , and because the French Lodges could not deal with it , they sent it to the Grand Lodge here to be dealt with . Last December twelvemonth , a petition was sent here on which the present motion was founded ; that petition was suffered to drop without remark , vote , or sympathy . ( No . ) He must remind the Grand Lodge , that the selection of the Freemasons' Society was a

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy