Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • March 1, 1857
  • Page 7
Current:

The Masonic Observer, March 1, 1857: Page 7

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, March 1, 1857
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article GRAND LODGE OF EMERGENCY. ← Page 4 of 4
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Emergency.

masonry . Any resolution on the subject could do no good ; all that Grand Lodge could offer was their deep and sincere sympathy , and that was all he hoped would be offered . The XV . Pro ., the Rev . G . PORTAL did not desire to impugn the statement of their Grand Chaplain , but he was bound to say that his own experience led him to the conclusion that the greatest misapprehension prevailed in some Roman Catholic countries , and he would instance France , as to what were the principles of Freemasons . When he was in Franco he mixed freelwith Roman Catholicsand

y , he' found , whenever he avowed himself to be a Freemason , that Roman Catholics shrank from him as if he wove an adder or some venomous reptile ; they said that it was his principle , as a Freemason , to stir up divisions wherever he went , ( loud and general laughter , in which the Rev . Bro . himself joined , ) this of course he denied . He knew that in our own country , Freemasons who were Roman Catholics , wore exposed to inconvenience on that account . Knowing thiswhen he saw a Roman Catholic at one of their Provinical

, Lodges , he asked him how he managed to continue a member , considering the objection of the Roman Catholic . Priesthood to the Craft ? Ho replied , " Oh , my priest is a good follow and lie lots us do as ive please in the matter . " Now he was of opinion that if a Statement were sent to foreign parts , showing the principles of Masonry , that Masons feared God and did not interfere in politics or religion—that statement might be shown by their Roman Catholic Brethren to their priesisand they might tell their priests

, they were not so black as they were painted , thus doing good and possibly disarming opposition . R . W . Bro . Lord PANMUIIE thought the Grand Lodge would fall into a serious mistake if they carried the motion . Whoever was persecuted tor hii opinions , was worthy of sympathy ; if they hold those opinions conscienciously they we ' re worthy of the sympathy of

all good men . If they were persecuted for holding the principles of Freemasonry , then he held that the persecutors wore guilty of a great crime ; but he did not think the sorrows of their Forei gn Brethren could be relieved by remonstrance . If the Grand Lodge had authority ovw those who wore the persecutors of Freemasonry , then he said it would be proper to remonstrate , and to interfere , to put oppression down ; but if they found they had no power over the oppressor , then they but made the persecution worse by interference . By the motionit was proposed to tell the world what all the world

, knew , and with respect to the principles of Masonry , he was aware that Roman Catholics had access to their secrets and knew them as well as any mason present . It was not necessary therefore to tell any class of Roman Catholics what the principles of Masonry were . If they attempted by a solemn resolution , and a solemn declaration of principles , to turn the tide of persecution , what would they do ? Why , they would give those very persecutors the means of putting on the Grand Lodge of Englanda direct and palpable insult

, , open , , in the face of the whole world . ( Cheers . ) Was that advisable ? He thought not , and therefore he must give his vote against the motion , on account of the position in which it would place them . XV . Bro . the Earl of CARNARVON , for one , could not acquiesce in the cold expression of mere sympathy , that was given to their Roman Catholic Brethren for the oppression they sustained . He would wish the Grand Lodge to put themselves right in the matter , and would leave the resolution in their handsHe " had been accused

. of bringing forward an inefficient measure , he had brought forward a measure that he thought the least objectionable , and most likely to be found readiest of adoption . He would simply leave the Grand Lodge to affirm or reject the motion ; believing that , if carried , it was calculated to afford benefit and solace to their suffering brethren abroad . The motion was put and declared to be lost .

TUB ADJOURNMENT OF GRAND LODGE . Bro , JAMES MASON , P . M ., No 168 , moved , "Any meeting of the Grand Lodge may , by a resolution of a majority of the members present at such meeting , and on a motion , of which no previous notice need be given , be adjourned , from time to time , for the discussion of and adjudication on any motion or other matter respecting which due communication shall have been previously made to the General Committee , and all undisposed of business on the agenda paper of the Lodge , at which any such Resolution for an adjournment shall be adopted , may be '

brought forward and disposed of at any such adjourned meeting . " There was much dissatisfaction at the mode in which the business of Grand Lodge was done—lie did not say that this was well founded , but it ought not to be disregarded , and it was the duty of all to join as one man , in the promotion of the interests of Masonry by supporting any motion that would have the effect of promoting their interests . He contended that more time ought to be given to the discussion of important motions than was afforded bv the time limited to the holding of Grand Lodge . W . Bro . WAURKN seconded the motion , observing that the present motion arose out of a motion to the same effect which he made last year , and which the Grand Master declared illegal . He must say

that ho thought the necessity for adjourned meetings of Grand Lodge to be imperative . Some remedy was needed to enable dropped motions to bo more promptly discussed . The present was an anomalous state of things which required to be remedied by some such motion as that now before Grand Lodge . W . Bro . J . H . STEEIIIKC would move his motion by way of amendment . It was to this efiect—that G . L . should adjourn to a day to lie fixed by the G . ill . It couid not be denied , tiiat the members of Grand Lodge required more opportunities of mcctin , ' : ;

for business , than they at present possessed . Provincial Masons were not satisfied with the present state of tilings . They came lon ^; distances , and were frequently sent back again , with their motions unconsidered * . XV . Bro . BINCKES seconded the amendment . Looking at the amount of the receipts , it must be inferred that a largo increase ot business had taken place , and that therefore a case was made out for more meetings of Grand Lodge . R . W . Bro . HALL would view the success of this motion with

apprehension . He objected to make Grand Lodge the arena of debate and of angry passions . No one could read without a blush , what had occurred recently within those walls . After much more to the same effect , and a glowing eulogium upon the excellence of the M . W . the G . M ., —the meeting became impatient ; and XV . Bro . BINCKES protested against W . Bro . Hall talking against time . W . Bro . ARIA repudiated the idea , that the motion had any reference to the Grand Master : he repudiated the charge of desiring

by the motion , to undermine the power of the Grand Master . W . Bro . T . TAYLOR denied that the business of Grand Lodge had increased , and saw no advantage in encouraging wider discussion . If the motion were carried , it would exclude Provincial Lodges , from taking part in discussions . R . XV . Bro . Lord PASMUUE , of the two motions before G . Lodge , preferred the last . When he heard the first motion read , he entertained serious apprehensions that one of their fundamental laws iras

to be overturned ; for if it were carried , it went at once to deprive the Grand Master of authority , that had been advisedly given to him . It would sanction the adjournment of Grand Lodge from day to day : it would in fact turn Grand Lodge from the specific purpose for which it was created , into a Masonic parliament . It would " not benefit the Craft to have discussion to such an extent . If the motion were carried , it would inconvenience members of Country Lodges , who would be kept in town eight or ten days , according to " the term

of adjournment , in order that fc ' liey might attend the adjourned meetings . Would it not be far better to let matters stand as they were , rather than to deprive the Grand Master of his constitutional power ? Would it not be better , first to test his willingness to call as many Grand Lodges as might be needed , before proceeding to change the existing law ? If the motions on the paper could not be got through that night—he would be the first to ask the Grand Master , to fix a day to hold a Lodge to go through them ; and if the Grand Master should refusethen he would be willing to transfer that power to

, Grand Lodge . It would be better to continue to regard with respect and reverence constituted authority—rather than to seek to change the laws day by day , to suit imaginary purposes and to redress imaginary grievances . W . Bro . MASON said , ihere were many meetings of Grand Lodge at which the Grand Master was not present , and it might fairly become a question whether the Acting G . Master should not have the power of adjournment when the state of the business required it .

He was satisfied that as adjournment would only occur for the discussion of important questions , it would bo for the advantage , and give satisfaction , to the whole body of Grand Lodge . The M . W , GRAND MASTER would briefly state his opinion of the motion . It had been urged , if this power of adjournment were conceded , that no adjournment would take place without just cause . The Worshipful Brother might be right in his supposition , but he would ask whether any considerable number of members had ever

expressed a wish in vain to him to summon a Grand Lodge ? He had never hesitated to summon a Grand Lodge as long as ho had filled that chair , when asked to do so by a competent ' number of brethren . He thought such a resolution as that before the Grand Lodge was , in reality , a motion of want of confidence in the G . M .. and , if carried , it would be an inducement for members of G . Lod ^ e to bring forward additional motions that were not required for the good of the Craft in generalBy such means Grand Lodge would

. ultimately become , as the Noble Brother had said , a mere Masonic parliament anil , instead of quarterly , tliero would be weekly communications , which would be inconvenient to Brethren In the country , who would be asked to come up to Grand Lodge every week or fortnight to attend the adjournments . If this vote indicating u want of confidence , were passed , lie should feel tumble to hold his position ; and he very much doubted whether any nobleman or gentleman , who had other business to engage them , would undertake the office o ' t'Grand . Uastc-r Tlio vote was put and lost ; and after the transaction o £ some unimportant business , at 11 o'clock the Lodge adjourned .

“The Masonic Observer: 1857-03-01, Page 7” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_01031857/page/7/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 4
GRAND LODGE OF EMERGENCY. Article 4
"ADDRESS TO THE CRAFT, BY A PAST MASTER." Article 8
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Article 10
MEMORIAL FROM THE PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF CANADA WEST. Article 10
BRO. THE EARL OF CARNARVON AT BATH. Article 12
A VALENTINE SOMEWHAT OVERDUE. Article 13
"THE MASONIC OBSERVER" TO HIS SHAMELESS LITTLE MUSE. Article 13
Untitled Article 14
Correspondence. Article 14
Untitled Article 15
From the " Canadian Masonic Pioneer." Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
"THE EARLY WITHDRAWAL OF THE BENEVOLENT—A LESSON TO SURVIVORS." Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

7 Articles
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Grand Lodge Of Emergency.

masonry . Any resolution on the subject could do no good ; all that Grand Lodge could offer was their deep and sincere sympathy , and that was all he hoped would be offered . The XV . Pro ., the Rev . G . PORTAL did not desire to impugn the statement of their Grand Chaplain , but he was bound to say that his own experience led him to the conclusion that the greatest misapprehension prevailed in some Roman Catholic countries , and he would instance France , as to what were the principles of Freemasons . When he was in Franco he mixed freelwith Roman Catholicsand

y , he' found , whenever he avowed himself to be a Freemason , that Roman Catholics shrank from him as if he wove an adder or some venomous reptile ; they said that it was his principle , as a Freemason , to stir up divisions wherever he went , ( loud and general laughter , in which the Rev . Bro . himself joined , ) this of course he denied . He knew that in our own country , Freemasons who were Roman Catholics , wore exposed to inconvenience on that account . Knowing thiswhen he saw a Roman Catholic at one of their Provinical

, Lodges , he asked him how he managed to continue a member , considering the objection of the Roman Catholic . Priesthood to the Craft ? Ho replied , " Oh , my priest is a good follow and lie lots us do as ive please in the matter . " Now he was of opinion that if a Statement were sent to foreign parts , showing the principles of Masonry , that Masons feared God and did not interfere in politics or religion—that statement might be shown by their Roman Catholic Brethren to their priesisand they might tell their priests

, they were not so black as they were painted , thus doing good and possibly disarming opposition . R . W . Bro . Lord PANMUIIE thought the Grand Lodge would fall into a serious mistake if they carried the motion . Whoever was persecuted tor hii opinions , was worthy of sympathy ; if they hold those opinions conscienciously they we ' re worthy of the sympathy of

all good men . If they were persecuted for holding the principles of Freemasonry , then he held that the persecutors wore guilty of a great crime ; but he did not think the sorrows of their Forei gn Brethren could be relieved by remonstrance . If the Grand Lodge had authority ovw those who wore the persecutors of Freemasonry , then he said it would be proper to remonstrate , and to interfere , to put oppression down ; but if they found they had no power over the oppressor , then they but made the persecution worse by interference . By the motionit was proposed to tell the world what all the world

, knew , and with respect to the principles of Masonry , he was aware that Roman Catholics had access to their secrets and knew them as well as any mason present . It was not necessary therefore to tell any class of Roman Catholics what the principles of Masonry were . If they attempted by a solemn resolution , and a solemn declaration of principles , to turn the tide of persecution , what would they do ? Why , they would give those very persecutors the means of putting on the Grand Lodge of Englanda direct and palpable insult

, , open , , in the face of the whole world . ( Cheers . ) Was that advisable ? He thought not , and therefore he must give his vote against the motion , on account of the position in which it would place them . XV . Bro . the Earl of CARNARVON , for one , could not acquiesce in the cold expression of mere sympathy , that was given to their Roman Catholic Brethren for the oppression they sustained . He would wish the Grand Lodge to put themselves right in the matter , and would leave the resolution in their handsHe " had been accused

. of bringing forward an inefficient measure , he had brought forward a measure that he thought the least objectionable , and most likely to be found readiest of adoption . He would simply leave the Grand Lodge to affirm or reject the motion ; believing that , if carried , it was calculated to afford benefit and solace to their suffering brethren abroad . The motion was put and declared to be lost .

TUB ADJOURNMENT OF GRAND LODGE . Bro , JAMES MASON , P . M ., No 168 , moved , "Any meeting of the Grand Lodge may , by a resolution of a majority of the members present at such meeting , and on a motion , of which no previous notice need be given , be adjourned , from time to time , for the discussion of and adjudication on any motion or other matter respecting which due communication shall have been previously made to the General Committee , and all undisposed of business on the agenda paper of the Lodge , at which any such Resolution for an adjournment shall be adopted , may be '

brought forward and disposed of at any such adjourned meeting . " There was much dissatisfaction at the mode in which the business of Grand Lodge was done—lie did not say that this was well founded , but it ought not to be disregarded , and it was the duty of all to join as one man , in the promotion of the interests of Masonry by supporting any motion that would have the effect of promoting their interests . He contended that more time ought to be given to the discussion of important motions than was afforded bv the time limited to the holding of Grand Lodge . W . Bro . WAURKN seconded the motion , observing that the present motion arose out of a motion to the same effect which he made last year , and which the Grand Master declared illegal . He must say

that ho thought the necessity for adjourned meetings of Grand Lodge to be imperative . Some remedy was needed to enable dropped motions to bo more promptly discussed . The present was an anomalous state of things which required to be remedied by some such motion as that now before Grand Lodge . W . Bro . J . H . STEEIIIKC would move his motion by way of amendment . It was to this efiect—that G . L . should adjourn to a day to lie fixed by the G . ill . It couid not be denied , tiiat the members of Grand Lodge required more opportunities of mcctin , ' : ;

for business , than they at present possessed . Provincial Masons were not satisfied with the present state of tilings . They came lon ^; distances , and were frequently sent back again , with their motions unconsidered * . XV . Bro . BINCKES seconded the amendment . Looking at the amount of the receipts , it must be inferred that a largo increase ot business had taken place , and that therefore a case was made out for more meetings of Grand Lodge . R . W . Bro . HALL would view the success of this motion with

apprehension . He objected to make Grand Lodge the arena of debate and of angry passions . No one could read without a blush , what had occurred recently within those walls . After much more to the same effect , and a glowing eulogium upon the excellence of the M . W . the G . M ., —the meeting became impatient ; and XV . Bro . BINCKES protested against W . Bro . Hall talking against time . W . Bro . ARIA repudiated the idea , that the motion had any reference to the Grand Master : he repudiated the charge of desiring

by the motion , to undermine the power of the Grand Master . W . Bro . T . TAYLOR denied that the business of Grand Lodge had increased , and saw no advantage in encouraging wider discussion . If the motion were carried , it would exclude Provincial Lodges , from taking part in discussions . R . XV . Bro . Lord PASMUUE , of the two motions before G . Lodge , preferred the last . When he heard the first motion read , he entertained serious apprehensions that one of their fundamental laws iras

to be overturned ; for if it were carried , it went at once to deprive the Grand Master of authority , that had been advisedly given to him . It would sanction the adjournment of Grand Lodge from day to day : it would in fact turn Grand Lodge from the specific purpose for which it was created , into a Masonic parliament . It would " not benefit the Craft to have discussion to such an extent . If the motion were carried , it would inconvenience members of Country Lodges , who would be kept in town eight or ten days , according to " the term

of adjournment , in order that fc ' liey might attend the adjourned meetings . Would it not be far better to let matters stand as they were , rather than to deprive the Grand Master of his constitutional power ? Would it not be better , first to test his willingness to call as many Grand Lodges as might be needed , before proceeding to change the existing law ? If the motions on the paper could not be got through that night—he would be the first to ask the Grand Master , to fix a day to hold a Lodge to go through them ; and if the Grand Master should refusethen he would be willing to transfer that power to

, Grand Lodge . It would be better to continue to regard with respect and reverence constituted authority—rather than to seek to change the laws day by day , to suit imaginary purposes and to redress imaginary grievances . W . Bro . MASON said , ihere were many meetings of Grand Lodge at which the Grand Master was not present , and it might fairly become a question whether the Acting G . Master should not have the power of adjournment when the state of the business required it .

He was satisfied that as adjournment would only occur for the discussion of important questions , it would bo for the advantage , and give satisfaction , to the whole body of Grand Lodge . The M . W , GRAND MASTER would briefly state his opinion of the motion . It had been urged , if this power of adjournment were conceded , that no adjournment would take place without just cause . The Worshipful Brother might be right in his supposition , but he would ask whether any considerable number of members had ever

expressed a wish in vain to him to summon a Grand Lodge ? He had never hesitated to summon a Grand Lodge as long as ho had filled that chair , when asked to do so by a competent ' number of brethren . He thought such a resolution as that before the Grand Lodge was , in reality , a motion of want of confidence in the G . M .. and , if carried , it would be an inducement for members of G . Lod ^ e to bring forward additional motions that were not required for the good of the Craft in generalBy such means Grand Lodge would

. ultimately become , as the Noble Brother had said , a mere Masonic parliament anil , instead of quarterly , tliero would be weekly communications , which would be inconvenient to Brethren In the country , who would be asked to come up to Grand Lodge every week or fortnight to attend the adjournments . If this vote indicating u want of confidence , were passed , lie should feel tumble to hold his position ; and he very much doubted whether any nobleman or gentleman , who had other business to engage them , would undertake the office o ' t'Grand . Uastc-r Tlio vote was put and lost ; and after the transaction o £ some unimportant business , at 11 o'clock the Lodge adjourned .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 6
  • You're on page7
  • 8
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy